Best Option
Compost: Shredded paper is compostable as long as it’s not colored or glossy.
Other Options:
Trash: Put this item in your trash.
Shredded, paper fragments are just too small to be sorted and processed for recycling in a single stream program. Plus shredded paper goes EVERYWHERE at the recycling center and sticks to and mixes in with other materials, decreasing the value of things like plastics, consuming more energy to process, and making recycling less efficient.